By Taylor Armerding
The Hendricks County Flyer
Fri Apr 19, 2013, 02:56 PM EDT
When are females younger than 17 considered girls? When they want an aspirin from the school nurse. In that case, the nurse needs permission from their parents. After all, legally they are juveniles - still children.
But when those same females want to buy a "morning-after" birth-control pill, they are considered "women" - adults who should have the right to make their own decisions about their bodies, free of any parental interference.
That is the Through-the-Looking-Glass world we now officially inhabit.
Yes, the definition of young teen (and even pre-teen) females has been bouncing between child and adult for some time, depending on the political issue, but now it has been given an extra sheen of legitimacy from a court.
Federal District Judge Edward R. Korman, of New York's Eastern District, recently overturned the 2011 decision by Health and Human Services Secretary Kathleen Sebelius to restrict access for girls younger than 17 to Plan B and other "morning-after" contraceptive pills by requiring that they have a prescription.
Korman declared Sebelius's decision to be, "arbitrary, capricious, and unreasonable."
This was, of course, "a big victory for women," in the words of Nancy Northup, president and CEO of the Center for Reproductive Rights. But she wasn't the only one shaping the terms to fit the agenda. National Public Radio reported that the judge had ordered that morning-after birth control be sold without a prescription to "women of all ages."
Gee, based on that, why not just retire the term "girl"?
And they call it a victory for "science." The monstrous absurdity of it would be funny, were it not so tragic for young girls, their families, and society in general.
Apparently, Judge Korman and those who applaud his decision believe that as soon as a female's body is able to conceive, science says she is a woman, with all the accompanying mental and emotional maturity of adulthood.
For starters, I'm wondering what that is going to do to laws that say a girl age 16 or younger cannot legally consent to sex. What is the point of a law like that for "women"?
Beyond that, shouldn't women of all ages - especially since they have a legal right to control their own bodies - be allowed to drive a car? Their vision, motor coordination, and reaction times are probably better than at least a third of the adult population. No need for arbitrary and capricious things like learner's permits and restricted licenses - these are women we're talking about!
Why shouldn't these "women" be allowed to vote? To hold a full-time job? To decide for themselves, without parental interference, that they would like to drop out of school? To move into their own apartment? To drink alcohol? To marry whomever they choose at whatever age they choose? What's the problem with a 12-year-old bride?
I seriously doubt that even Judge Korman would say yes to any of those. I suspect even Nancy Northrup wouldn't. They'd probably label anyone who did as crazy.
In those cases, these young females suddenly morph into "girls" - children who should be restricted from activities that an allegedly enlightened society has decided they are not mature enough to handle. In areas like alcohol use, driving, and voting, you can read scholarly scientific studies that note the obvious - that the brains of adolescents are still developing and are dangerously short of sound, adult judgment.
Apparently, politics trumps that kind of science.
You, my outspoken fans and equally outspoken critics, know I rarely agree with President Obama's policy decisions. But on this issue, he is absolutely correct. I applaud his willingness to say what any sane adult would say in these circumstances - that it violates "common sense" to let juvenile females make potentially life-altering decisions on their own.
As Dr. Marc Siegel, associate professor of medicine at New York University, noted recently, these circumstances are when a doctor should be involved.
"A good doctor knows how responsible her patient is, what the risks of taking a drug are, and whether a medication such as the morning-after pill is being used appropriately for an unexpected emergency or is actually encouraging more reckless sex and promiscuity," he wrote.
And even if most young teens use it appropriately, Siegel cites studies that show those who don't can suffer from vomiting, cramping, or excess bleeding.
Whatever happened to the "if-it-saves-even-one-life" mantra from the left-wingers who are applauding this decision?
Labeling a girl a woman, even if it is a judge doing it, does not make it so. Ask any caring and concerned parents of a 14-year-old girl if their daughter is a woman and they will likely ask if you are joking.
Most of them think even their 17- and 18-year-olds are children. I can't count the number of times when, as a local newspaper editor, frantic parents would call or come into the office, desperate to keep news about the arrest of their offspring out of the paper. "He (or she) is just a kid," they would declare, sometimes in tears.
I took no pleasure in telling them that in the eyes of the law, their kids are adults.
"Your problem is with society, not me," I told them.
A judge who declares that kids are adults when it comes to sex and emergency birth control is not doing anyone any favors, especially these vulnerable young girls.
- Taylor Armerding is an independent columnist. Contact him at email@example.com.
March 3, 2014
February 27, 2014
February 26, 2014
There was a wide array of reactions to Seattle DB Richard Sherman’s post-game “interview” with Erin Andrews following the Seahawks’ NFC title win over San Francisco.
Mine? Laughter, as the shout-down was the most entertaining thing I saw all day.
January 28, 2014
Butler is still a long way from saving its 2013-14 men’s basketball season, but if the Bulldogs turn it around fully and reach the NCAA Tournament, it will have started this past Saturday at Hinkle Fieldhouse.
January 21, 2014
A fine season for the Indianapolis Colts ended with a whimper Saturday at New England, but in recent team history, it was far from the most disappointing postseason defeat.
January 14, 2014
The Indianapolis Colts’ miraculous 45-44 wild card victory over Kansas City on Saturday ended just after 8 p.m. After leaving Lucas Oil Stadium, it took until around midnight for the pounding in my head to subside.
January 7, 2014
December 31, 2013
An NPR broadcast examines the question of how communities can better prepare for tornadoes like the one that struck Moore, Okla. on Monday. The broadcast features commentary from Michael Fitzgerald, who reported a five-part disaster series for the CNHI News Service.
May 22, 2013
Part I: Are We Prepared? | Part II: Disaster Dollars Part III: Lessons Learned | Part IV: Warning Signs Part V: The Big One
In a tearful statement that went viral this week, Kentucky Attorney General Jack Conway announced that he would not defend his state's ban on gay marriage in court. Conway made the announcement after a federal judge ruled that Kentucky must recognize same sex marriages performed in other states. However, Gov. Steve Beshear said he will hire private attorneys to appeal the judge's order.
March 6, 2014
© 2014 Community Newspaper Holdings, Inc. ·
CNHI Classified Advertising Network ·
CNHI News Service
Associated Press content © 2014. All rights reserved. AP content may not be published,
broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.
Our site is powered by Zope. Some parts of our site may require
you to download the Flash Player Plugin.
Terms and Conditions
Hendricks County Flyer, Avon, IN
8109 Kingston St., Suite 500